- 2010[16] David Bryan & Daryl Waters – Memphis
- Jason Carr – La Cage aux Folles
- Aaron Johnson – Fela!
- Jonathan Tunick – Promises, Promises
- 2011[17] Larry Hochman & Stephen Oremus – The Book of Mormon
- Doug Besterman – How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying
- Larry Blank & Marc Shaiman – Catch Me If You Can
- Larry Hochman– The Scottsboro Boys
- 2012[18] Martin Lowe – Once
- Bill Brohn & Christopher Jahnke – Porgy and Bess
- Bill Elliott – Nice Work If You Can Get It
- Danny Troob – Newsies
- 2013[19] Stephen Oremus – Kinky Boots
- Bryan Crook & Ethan Popp – Motown: The Musical
- Chris Nightingale – Matilda the Musical
- Danny Troob – Rodgers and Hammerstein's Cinderella
- 2014[20] Jason Robert Brown – The Bridges of Madison County
- Doug Besterman – Bullets Over Broadway
- Steve Sidwell – Beautiful: The Carole King Musical
- Jonathan Tunick – A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder
| - 2015[21] Christopher Austin, Bill Elliott & Don Sebesky – An American in Paris
- 2016[22] Alex Lacamoire – Hamilton
- August Eriksmoen – Bright Star
- Larry Hochman – She Loves Me
- Daryl Waters – Shuffle Along
- 2017[23] Alex Lacamoire – Dear Evan Hansen
- 2018[24] Jamshied Sharifi – The Band's Visit
- John Clancy – Mean Girls
- Tom Kitt – SpongeBob SquarePants
- Annmarie Milazzo & Michael Starobin – Once on This Island
- Jonathan Tunick – Carousel
- 2019[25] Michael Chorney & Todd Sickafoose – Hadestown
|