1956 London Heathrow Avro Vulcan crash
![]() A Vulcan B.1A similar to the accident aircraft | |
Accident | |
---|---|
Date | 1 October 1956 (1956-10-01) |
Summary | Pilot error |
Site | London Heathrow Airport |
Aircraft | |
Aircraft type | Avro Vulcan |
Operator | Royal Air Force |
Registration | XA897 |
Flight origin | No. 230 Operational Conversion Unit RAF, RAF Waddington |
Last stopover | RAF Khormaksar, Aden |
Destination | London Heathrow Airport |
Passengers | 1 (Technical advisor from the Avro company) |
Crew | 5 |
Fatalities | 4 |
Survivors | 2 |
The 1956 London Heathrow Avro Vulcan crash was a military aviation accident that occurred at Heathrow Airport on 1 October 1956 when Avro Vulcan B.1 XA897 crashed while attempting to land in poor weather. The captain and co-pilot ejected safely but the remaining three crew and one passenger were killed.[1]
Background
XA897 was the first Vulcan bomber delivered to the Royal Air Force; after arriving at RAF Waddington, the aircraft was loaned to C-in-C Air Marshal Sir Harry Broadhurst and Squadron Leader Donald "Podge" Howard for a 26,000 mi (42,000 km; 23,000 nmi) round the world trip to showcase the aircraft's advanced design. Between 9 September and 1 October 1956, XA897 flew to Australia and New Zealand and was accompanied by three Avro Shackletons containing ground-crew and parts to service the Vulcan.
Leaving Australia, the Vulcan flew to RAF Khormaksar in Aden. It took off from there at 02:50 hours GMT and was scheduled to arrive shortly after 10 o'clock in the morning at London Heathrow.
Accident
The Vulcan had been fitted with bomb bay fuel tanks to cover the great distance from Aden and the aircraft approached Heathrow in torrential rain. At the controls were Howard and, co-pilot, Broadhurst. In the rear of the aircraft were three RAF crewmen and a civilian technical advisor from Avro.
Due to the heavy rain and visibility reduced to 500 ft (150 m), XA897 was on a ground controlled approach (GCA) and was informed by Heathrow's air traffic controller that they were above the glide slope (GS) and needed to lose altitude. The crew reduced height too much, with their air speed close to the minimum drag point for a gear down configuration. As a result, the Vulcan was 1,030 yd (940 m) short of the runway and the initial contact with the ground removed the aircraft's undercarriage.
The pilot attempted to regain control but was unable and he and the co-pilot both ejected. The low level made it impossible for Squadron Leader Stroud (Howard's regular co-pilot who was in the aircraft's radar navigator's seat), Squadron Leader Eames, Squadron Leader Gamble, and Frederick Bassett to exit the aircraft[clarification needed] and they were killed.
Cause
The court of inquiry convened to review the crash determined that XA897's approach was affected by poor visibility due to heavy rain (three Russian Tu-104 aircraft carrying the Bolshoi Ballet had already been diverted away from Heathrow to RAF Manston that morning) and that the aircraft was not equipped to use the instrument landing system (ILS) installed at Heathrow. The approach to Runway 10L was undertaken using a ground controlled approach (GCA) (the first time Howard had done this). Howard attempted to abort the landing believing he was at 150 ft (46 m) he applied power but his aircraft collided with the ground which removed his undercarriage and severely damaged the Vulcan's control surfaces. The aircraft's port wing was almost vertical and with no prospect of recovery he and Broadhurst ejected. The low level made it impossible for Stroud, Eames, Gamble, and Bassett to exit the aircraft and they were killed.
Later claim of accident cause
In 2016 Maurice Hamlin, a former member of the RAF on duty the day of the crash, claimed in his book The Hidden Truth that Harry Broadhurst ignored three direct orders to divert away from Heathrow due to the poor weather conditions (noting other aircraft had already been diverted). Hamlin believes that Broadhurst continued to attempt to land despite such orders due to the waiting press and dignitaries. He further claims that a fifty-year D-Notice had been placed on the incident,[2] even though numerous Air Ministry and Board of Trade files relating to the crash are available at the UK National Archives.[3]
Timeline
- 02:50 GMT - XA897 leaves Aden
- 09:58 GMT - XA897 informed weather at London Heathrow as 2/8ths cloud at 300 ft (91 m); 7/8ths cloud at 700 ft (210 m); main cloud base 5,000 ft (1,500 m); visibility 1,100 yd (1,000 m); heavy rain and little wind.
- (XA897 had sufficient fuel to divert to RAF Waddington if required where the weather forecast was 1/8th cloud at 600 ft (180 m); 3/8ths at 8,000 ft (2,400 m); main base 13,000 ft (4,000 m); visibility 3 nautical miles.)
- 10:04 GMT - the Vulcan was at 1,500 ft (460 m), five miles from touch down on Runway 10 Left, and began its descent under GCA with a QNH of 1017 millibars both set on the Captain's and co-pilot's altimeters.
- (The Captain started the approach and went above the glide path by 80 ft (24 m), then over correcting and going 100 ft (30 m) too low, believing he was on the correct glide path.)
- 10:05 - at 1,030 yd (940 m) from touch down XA897 made initial contact with the ground, removing both main undercarriage units.
Notes
- ^ "Vulcan Aircraft Crash (Report)". Parliamentary Debates (Hansard). 20 December 1956. Retrieved 13 December 2014.
- ^ "Maurice's book has few equals". Archived from the original on 25 September 2015. Retrieved 24 September 2015.
- ^ "The Discovery Service".
Bibliography
- RAF Court of Inquiry into accident involving Vulcan XA897 at London Airport on 1 October 1956 - The National Archives
External links
- "Anniversary of Vulcan crash" BBC News, 19 September 2008.
- Aviation Safety Network accident report
- A 1957 Flight article on the official report: ""Dr. Touch's Report on the Vulcan Accident"". Archived from the original on 5 March 2018. Retrieved 6 March 2024.
- House of Commons debate
- v
- t
- e
1910
- Thomas Harris (May 1824)
- Cecil Shadbolt (July 1892)
- Percy Pilcher (October 1899)
- Charles Rolls (July 1910)
- Cecil Grace (December 1910)
- Brooklands Flanders Monoplane (May 1912)
- Cody Floatplane (August 1913)
- Maxstoke (August 1918)
- Transatlantic flight of Alcock and Brown (June 1919)
- Airship N.S.11 (July 1919)
- Golders Green Handley Page O/400 (December 1920)
- R38-class airship (June 1921)
- Air Union Farman Goliath (August 1923)
- Daimler Airway de Havilland DH.34 (September 1923)
- KLM Fokker F.III disappearance (April 1924)
- Imperial Airways de Havilland DH.34 (December 1924)
- Air Union Blériot 155 (August 1926)
- Air Union Blériot 155 (October 1926)
- KLM Fokker F.VIII (August 1927)
- Imperial Airways Handley Page W.10 (June 1929)
- Luft Hansa Junkers G 24 (November 1929)
- Air Union Farman Goliath (February 1930)
- Meopham air disaster (July 1930)
- London, Scottish & Provincial Airways Airspeed Courier (September 1934)
- Hillman's Airways de Havilland Dragon Rapide (October 1934)
- SABENA Savoia-Marchetti S.73 (December 1935)
- Jersey Air Disaster (July 1936)
- KLM Croydon accident (December 1936)
- Edmonton air crash (September 1938)
- Jersey Airport disaster (November 1938)
- Dunbeath air crash (August 1942)
- Ruislip Wellington accident (October 1942)
- RAF Hudson (May 1943)
- Gibraltar Liberator AL523 (July 1943)
- Moordown air disaster (March 1944)
- Freckleton air disaster (August 1944)
- USAAF Boeing B-17 on North Barrule (April 1945)
- Elvetham air crash (October 1945)
- Broadway Consolidated Liberator (November 1945)
- Railway Air Services Dakota (December 1946)
- BOAC Douglas C-47 (January 1947)
- Croydon Dakota accident (January 1947)
- Heathrow disaster (March 1948)
- Northwood mid-air collision (July 1948)
- KLM Constellation air disaster (October 1948)
- Exhall mid-air collision (February 1949)
- Manchester BEA Douglas DC-3 accident (August 1949)
- Llandow air disaster (March 1950)
- Heathrow BEA Vickers Viking (October 1950)
- Ringway Dakota (March 1951)
- Aer Lingus C-47 accident (January 1952)
- Farnborough Airshow crash (September 1952)
- Little Rissington UFO incident (October 1952)
- Aldbury Valetta accident (January 1954)
- Swissair Convair CV-240 (June 1954)
- Prestwick air disaster (December 1954)
- Hawker Hunter multiple aircraft accident (February 1956)
- RAF Lakenheath nuclear near-disaster (July 1956)
- London Heathrow Avro Vulcan (October 1956)
- Sutton Wick air crash (March 1957)
- British European Airways Flight 411 (March 1957)
- Blackbushe Viking accident (May 1957)
- Nutts Corner BEA Viscount (October 1957
- Aquila Airways Solent (November 1957)
- Winter Hill air disaster (February 1958)
- London Vickers Viking accident (September 1958)
- Syerston Avro Vulcan (September 1958)
- BOAC Bristol Britannia (December 1958)
- Turkish Airlines Gatwick (February 1959)
- Channel Airways Dakota accident (May 1962)
- BAC One-Eleven test crash (October 1963)
- British United Airways Flight 1030X (April 1965)
- Little Baldon air crash (July 1965)
- Skyways Coach-Air Avro 748 (July 1965)
- Cambrian Airways Liverpool (July 1965)
- Pan Am Flight 292 (September 1965)
- British European Airways Flight 706 (October 1965)
- Felthorpe Trident crash (June 1966)
- Holden's Lightning flight (July 1966)
- Stockport air disaster (June 1967)
- Iberia Flight 062 (November 1967)
- Hawker Hunter Tower Bridge incident (April 1968)
- BOAC Flight 712 (April 1968)
- BKS Air Transport Flight C.6845 (July 1968)
- Ariana Afghan Airlines Flight 701 (January 1969)
- 1969 theft of C-130 (May 1969)
- British European Airways Flight 548 (June 1972)
- Court Line Flight 95 (April 1974)
- British Airways bombing attempt (July 1974)
- Norfolk mid-air collision (August 1974)
- Graham Hill plane crash (November 1975)
- British Airtours Boeing 707 crash (March 1977)
- British Army Gazelle downing (February 1978)
- Dan-Air Flight 0034 (July 1979)
- Biggin Hill Invader crash (September 1980)
- Aer Lingus Flight 164 (May 1981)
- Dan-Air Flight 240 (June 1981)
- Bristow Helicopters Westland Wessex crash (August 1981)
- British Army Gazelle friendly fire incident (June 1982)
- British Airways Sikorsky S-61 crash (July 1983)
- Manchester Airport disaster (August 1985)
- Hindawi affair (April 1986)
- British Army Lynx shootdown (June 1988)
- British International Helicopters Sikorsky S-61N crash (July 1988)
- Pan Am Flight 103 (December 1988)
- template
- Kegworth air disaster (January 1989)
- British Army Gazelle shootdown (February 1990)
- Scotland RAF Shackleton crash (April 1990)
- British Airways Flight 5390 (June 1990)
- Llyn Padarn helicopter crash (August 1993)
- British Army Lynx shootdown (March 1994)
- Mull of Kintyre Chinook crash (June 1994)
- Air Algérie Flight 702P (December 1994)
- Bristow Helicopters Flight 56C (January 1995)
- Royal Air Force Nimrod R1 ditching (May 1995)
- Knight Air Flight 816 (May 1995)
- Virgin Atlantic Flight 024 (November 1997)
- Edinburgh Air Charter Flight 3W (September 1999)
- Korean Air Cargo Flight 8509 (December 1999)
- Loganair Flight 670A (February 2001)
- British Airways Flight 268 (February 2005)
- Loganair Islander accident (March 2005)
- Morecambe Bay Eurocopter AS365 crash (December 2006)
- Alderney UFO sighting (April 2007)
- British Airways Flight 38 (January 2008)
- Biggin Hill Cessna Citation crash (March 2008)
- Vauxhall helicopter crash (January 2013)
- CHC Scotia Flight 23R (August 2013)
- Glasgow helicopter crash (November 2013)
- Haughey Air AgustaWestland AW139 crash (March 2014)
- Loganair Flight 6780 (December 2014)
- Blackbushe Phenom 300 crash (July 2015)
- Shoreham Airshow crash (August 2015)
- Leicester helicopter crash (October 2018)
- Gatwick Airport drone incident (December 2018)
- English Channel Piper PA-46 crash (January 2019)